TBURGESS

What a dumb question. I thought you were smarter than that. Why would any GM save the money only to have it go away at the end of the year. As discussed earlier... Walters would use likely use it to extend players using this years cap which would give us more room next year or to bring in a couple of difference makers to get us over the hump at the end of the season, maybe even to sign a NI draft pick who is currently in the NFL. We went on about a million dollar spending spree in the off season. A. Harris, M. Harris, Smith, Dressler, Shologan, Cummings and Keeping are making more than the guys they replaced. -250K for Moore + Denmark and then we re-signed Denmark so some of that isn't actually off the books. I'd guess we are closer to the top of the SMS than we've ever been since the big 3 took over. One move, cutting Willy, which I know we won't do, would give us an extra 200K or so cushion.

On the radio the other day they were talking about a 22K game day cheque for Willy (I'm not vouching for the accuracy of this statement). That's 396K in game day checks leaving 15K for bonuses. I'll assume a 10K TC bonus that we've already paid out and 5K in performance bonuses that won't be paid out cuz that's how I roll. Willy's a vet. Gotta cut him by week 10 or pay the whole salary IIRC which leaves 10 game day cheques or $220,000 plus the 5K in bonuses he didn't earn for $225K. Take 50K off to promote our PR QB to 3rd string and we're down to 175K of SMS room to do whatever we need to with this year and more than 400K next year

The longer we wait, the more money Willy gets and the less SMS relief we get. If you sign someone for 150K mid-season (Using Mikes numbers rather than debating what neither of us knows for sure), you're paying out 75K for half a season. You'd have to sign someone at 300K to use the whole 150K on half a seasons salary.

I'll go with Messam.

The same folks who snort derisively and laugh at Taman for his SMS mistakes, have no problem with Walters using 400K+ of our SMS on a backup QB. SMH! For the same money, I'd take Willy over the other 2, but the other 2 would be around 175K and Willy's over 400K and yes... That means a lot.

Come on man... Willy was 1-4 this year and was replaced by Nichols for good reasons, yet you want to go back to when he was Durant's backup to make your point. I'm not pretending that he's a worthless player. I'm saying outright that he's an overpaid backup with very limited successes.

That's where you lose me. Willy hasn't proven to be a capable QB except for 5 games back in 2014. For his level of play we could get Brandon Bridge or Dan LeFevour for less than half what we are paying Willy.

I don't think Willy is a great depth QB at the moment. I seriously doubt that time on the pine will result in him being able to turn it around if he's called upon. His contract makes him untradeable, which means other teams wouldn't want him at his current salary. You're happy to pay it because Davis might not be able to get the job done and Bennett might not be a good enough 3rd string QB. Most don't agree with asking Willy to take a pay cut, which limits the options to cut him or keep him. Cut him allows you to use the money for other things. Keep him allows you to have a backup QB who is experienced in losing.

It seems to me that a lot of Willy fans want to keep him around so he can go back in and prove the Nichols fans wrong, no matter the cost. FTR: I don't think it's time to cut Willy yet. It's only been 2 games, but it's certainly time to put a plan in place. Calling Willy a decent backup QB who we have to keep would be great if he was being paid less than half of what he's currently making. He was overpaid as a starter now he's way overpaid. $400+K for a depth player is a ridiculous waste of SMS. I doubt the Bombers will cut Willy because that would highlight the fact that they made a huge mistake in giving him top QB contract before he became a top QB in the first place. I also suspect they still believe in him despite what's happened this year. The SMS space could be used to increase our depth elsewhere or extend the contracts using this years money or bring in upgrades elsewhere.

So that would be a no then.

Did Lulay lose his job while he was healthy? Was Lulay sucking down a top 5 in the league salary? Nope. cause you know, you want one of the top paid players in the league to actually play and earn his huge salary and the money should be used to improve the team.

The 5th highest paid player in the league is our backup QB because his job has been taken by Nichols, but we need to keep him on the roster until the end of the year just in case he turns he game around on the bench or in case our cheaper starter goes down? That's the argument?

It's funny that most people don't want to see Willy anymore because they don't see him as a starter and because he was a big part of the reason we were losing so often. The same people also argue that we have to keep Willy with his ridiculously large contract because he's the only experienced backup we have and we may need him. I don't see how he can be both too bad to start and too good to let go especially at $400-411K.

That game was hard to watch. Ottawa took 14 accepted penalties for 204 yards, while Edmonton chipped in with 13 for 105. Add in stoppages for turnovers and challenges and you end up with a close yawn fest. The Burris rant and the amount of punishment Reilly can take were the highlights. BTW when did they change the rule on hitting the upright on a FG? Used to be if you hit it and it went in you got 3. Hit it and it went into or through the end zone you get 1. Hit it and it comes back out and you get nothing. Now you get nothing if you hit it and it goes in or through the end zone. Could have been the difference in this game.

Cuz Winnipegers are cheap and they don't like the idea of not getting their money's worth out of Willy. Also, it's bad form to have highest paid player on the team being a $400K+ backup insurance policy.

The Redblacks have the top offense in the league and a top half of league defense. The Esks have the second best offense in the league and one of the worst defenses. Hopefully a high scoring close game, but I have to think that an extra week will go a long way to fixing Burris's problems and the Redblacks will prevail.

Jennings is a very good young QB for a 24 year old. He's still learning the position and he's putting together some wins. He was 84.4% completions for 331 yards against a very good Montreal defense. What do folks expect from a young QB around here? I'd take him over any of our QB's. The Stamps game was close until the 4th when the Stamps scored 16 unanswered points and Messam ran for about 75 yards. If you like to watch the Riders lose, just tune in again next week as it's back to back.

Fair enough.

Is GarrettB GBill? See point 3 in: http://3downnation.com/2016/08/04/nichols-bombers-back-track-_-thoughts/ by John Hodge.

Toronto with Hardrick is definitely beatable.

I'll bet that Willy's contract has way more guaranteed money and way less bonuses built in. One 'source' said he got over 100K up front this year. Again, I have no idea if it's true or not.

No, but the amount of bonus money that Nichols will get did. I saw a tweet that said Nichols gets $100K bonus if he starts 6 games. Now, I've got no idea if that's true or not, but I have to believe that his contract is bonus laden.

That surprised me too. I wouldn't have put Masoli back in after the half.

Some concern, but not a lot because we were sitting on a lead in garbage time. A bigger question to me is why were Nichols and Harris still in the game late in the 4th quarter? An injury to either one could completely derail our season.

At least you could have made it a poll.