rebusrankin Posted July 31, 2017 Report Posted July 31, 2017 The fact remains it was called a touchdown, we won the game and for the rest of time, you will be able to read about how Harris scored the winning touchdown in the game, capping a sensational comeback. SPuDS and Mr Dee 2
Yourface Posted July 31, 2017 Report Posted July 31, 2017 Maybe it's the altruist in me but I don't feel a sense of pride from winning a football game based on poor officiating.
17to85 Posted July 31, 2017 Report Posted July 31, 2017 eh, if Montreal had won we'd have just as much cause to ***** about the refs as they would. That dive to draw the PI just before their very first TD was as bad as anything else in that game. Here is the thing, the reffing in the CFL is atrocious, we know this, and they called a TD for Harris on the field so you need 100% evidence to over turn it, there was none, score stands. Montreal should be ashamed of themselves for taking their foot off the gas at the end and letting Winnipeg twice march it right down their throats. That's not reffing, that's soft D putting themselves in a position where it even came down to that. Sard 1
SPuDS Posted July 31, 2017 Report Posted July 31, 2017 11 minutes ago, Yourface said: Maybe it's the altruist in me but I don't feel a sense of pride from winning a football game based on poor officiating. THERE WAS NO POOR OFFICIATING ON THE PLAY.. jesus christ! get over yourself. you are wrong, move along. everyone and their dogs are saying it.. what else do you need to hear? Maybe the TSN analyst can call you and walk you thru all the feeds he viewed (as they get them all and shockingly, the best views available) and explain in detail how you are so wrong? seriously man, dead horse.. you with a bat wailing away. The guy has zero connection to winnipeg so why would he be lying to cover up some nefarious plot? Sard, Mr Dee and JCon 2 1
TBURGESS Posted July 31, 2017 Report Posted July 31, 2017 (edited) The Refs seem to call everything that's close a TD these days. Is it because they know that it will be automatically reviewed if they call it a TD and it won't be if they don't? The byproduct of doing that is more TD's because there's rarely enough evidence to overturn calls, which is what the CFL wants in the first place. FTR and in hopes of not getting any more involved in this debate... I can't tell for sure if Harris was in before he touched the ground or not. I submit that anyone who says they can is fooling themselves. Edited July 31, 2017 by TBURGESS bearpants 1
SPuDS Posted July 31, 2017 Report Posted July 31, 2017 Just now, TBURGESS said: The Refs seem to call everything that's close a TD these days. Is it because they know that it will be automatically reviewed if they call it a TD and it won't be if they don't? They byproduct of doing that is more TD's because there's rarely enough evidence to overturn calls, which is what the CFL wants in the first place. FTR and in hopes of not getting any more involved in this debate... I can't tell for sure if Harris was in before he touched the ground or not. I submit that anyone who says they can is fooling themselves. so you say TSN is lying when they say they had something like a dozen different views and angles and that they concluded after watching them all that he scored and was not down? rebusrankin and Tracker 2
Jpan85 Posted July 31, 2017 Report Posted July 31, 2017 To me it looked his hand went down first and as his body was rolling over the elbow did touch but you can't tell if the ball crossed the line or not so that would be inclusive. If the ALS wanted to win they would of not run out of bounds a couple times on there last drive.
Bigblue204 Posted July 31, 2017 Report Posted July 31, 2017 24 minutes ago, Yourface said: Maybe it's the altruist in me but I don't feel a sense of pride from winning a football game based on poor officiating. you shouldn't feel any pride. You didn't win anything. rebusrankin and SPuDS 2
TBURGESS Posted July 31, 2017 Report Posted July 31, 2017 2 minutes ago, SPuDS said: so you say TSN is lying when they say they had something like a dozen different views and angles and that they concluded after watching them all that he scored and was not down? I knew someone would try to drag me into this. I don't even know if there are a dozen different cameras or a dozen different angles to look at in a regular season CFL game. Certainly no one on these boards has seen so many angles, yet many know for sure that he was either in for a TD or he wasn't. That's bollocks.
SPuDS Posted July 31, 2017 Report Posted July 31, 2017 31 minutes ago, TBURGESS said: I knew someone would try to drag me into this. I don't even know if there are a dozen different cameras or a dozen different angles to look at in a regular season CFL game. Certainly no one on these boards has seen so many angles, yet many know for sure that he was either in for a TD or he wasn't. That's bollocks. An analyst from TSN, Chris Edwards, after seeing social media and football discussion groups blowing up about this call, tweeted out that he had viewed a dozen different shots and angles of the play and definitively and emphatically stated it was a clear TD and there was zero supporting evidence that he was down either by knee or elbow.. So.. again.. if you are keeping score. thats one TSN analyst who had a bunch of views none of us had 1, rest of naysayer's.. 0. unless you don't believe a guy whos willing to put his job on the line at TSN.. JCon and Mr Dee 2
Yourface Posted July 31, 2017 Report Posted July 31, 2017 46 minutes ago, Bigblue204 said: you shouldn't feel any pride. You didn't win anything. It's called civic pride. Maybe a feeling that's hard to come by among Winnipeggers.
blue_gold_84 Posted July 31, 2017 Report Posted July 31, 2017 1 minute ago, Yourface said: It's called civic pride. Maybe a feeling that's hard to come by among Winnipeggers. Spoken like someone who has no clue. Nothing says classy like taking digs at an entire city, but you claim you're an objective and unbiased altruist... LOL SPuDS hit the nail on the head: get over yourself. Bigblue204, SPuDS, Yourface and 1 other 3 1
JCon Posted July 31, 2017 Report Posted July 31, 2017 The Montreal game is the only home game I will have to miss all season. Away on vacation. Hope I didn't miss much. I was able to watch some of the game and listen to the entire thing (while packing to return from vacation). I was even happier when my Rider neighbours came knocking on my door with to watch the end of the game. They were in 'jolly' moods until the onside kick was recovered. blue_gold_84 and SPuDS 1 1
Bigblue204 Posted July 31, 2017 Report Posted July 31, 2017 10 minutes ago, Yourface said: It's called civic pride. Maybe a feeling that's hard to come by among Winnipeggers. lol go plow a field you sister ******* tool. Yourface, blue_gold_84 and SPuDS 3
Mark H. Posted July 31, 2017 Report Posted July 31, 2017 Ok, I do believe we're done here. blue_gold_84 and SPuDS 2
Recommended Posts