All things considered...

[bluto]

14 hours ago, 17to85 said:

It that really a high bar though?

Demean, denigrate and disparage all you like. But being among the greatest head coaches in the history of the most successful and storied Canadian football team after a mere 4 years at the helm is no mean feat. If we win 8 games next year, he'll be tied with Leo Cahill for 3rd most wins.

 

[17to85]

Toronto suck

[bluto]

50 minutes ago, 17to85 said:

Toronto suck from the Grey Cup.

 

[wbbfan]

1 hour ago, bluto said:

Demean, denigrate and disparage all you like. But being among the greatest head coaches in the history of the most successful and storied Canadian football team after a mere 4 years at the helm is no mean feat. If we win 8 games next year, he'll be tied with Leo Cahill for 3rd most wins.

 

Some teams have a history that includes long stretches of great coaching. Especially the buono teams. 
 The Argos and bombers are not those teams. We’ve both succeeding with fleeting runs of truly top level coaching. 
 Mos and dinwiddie are quickly rising in the ranks of all time coaches when it comes to wins and gcs. And dinwiddie is a brilliant tactician. Neither guy has entered the level of buono, the don, etc. 

It’s like Emmitt smith becoming the all time rushing leader. He isn’t a top 5 back of all time or in that tier. He is for forever in the shadow of Guys like Payton, sanders and brown. 

[bluto]

14 minutes ago, wbbfan said:

Some teams have a history that includes long stretches of great coaching. Especially the buono teams. 
 The Argos and bombers are not those teams. We’ve both succeeding with fleeting runs of truly top level coaching. 
 Mos and dinwiddie are quickly rising in the ranks of all time coaches when it comes to wins and gcs. And dinwiddie is a brilliant tactician. Neither guy has entered the level of buono, the don, etc. 

It’s like Emmitt smith becoming the all time rushing leader. He isn’t a top 5 back of all time or in that tier. He is for forever in the shadow of Guys like Payton, sanders and brown. 

The Don is a legend around here. And Coach Din (46) is going to pass him (49) and likely Cahill (54) this coming season. Then he only has Pinball (67) and Obie (89). And Dinwiddie has the highest win percentage of them and if he gets one more cup here he'll pass every one of our post WW2 coaches.

Remarkable stuff.

 

I'd do the same lookup for O'Shea (and Mass, who I have been very impressed with), but the Wiki for the Bombers coaches only says it goes to the end of the 2022 season. One of you guys should go edit it.

EDIT: Pretty sure that O'Shea owns most of your HC records now?

Edited December 13, 2024 by bluto

[HardCoreBlue]

1 hour ago, bluto said:

Demean, denigrate and disparage all you like. But being among the greatest head coaches in the history of the most successful and storied Canadian football team after a mere 4 years at the helm is no mean feat. If we win 8 games next year, he'll be tied with Leo Cahill for 3rd most wins.

 

For some of us, don't care.

Welcome to a Winnipeg Blue Bomber site.

Enjoy your stay.

[17to85]

1 hour ago, bluto said:

 

Toronto sucks all the time. 

[HardCoreBlue]

2 minutes ago, 17to85 said:

Toronto sucks all the time. 

I would add 'in general' right after the word Toronto. 🙂

[Fatty Liver]

5 hours ago, bluto said:

Demean, denigrate and disparage all you like. But being among the greatest head coaches in the history of the most successful and storied Canadian football team after a mere 4 years at the helm is no mean feat. If we win 8 games next year, he'll be tied with Leo Cahill for 3rd most wins.

 

Watched a podcast with Dinwiddie last year, seemed to indicate he has a pretty high interest in coaching in the US, college or pro.  Like Mike Riley, still being young he might be an attractive option to take over a college program and grow from there.  Unless he's developed a fond attachment to living in Toronto, he could be long-gone within a season or two.  

[bluto]

2 hours ago, 17to85 said:

Toronto sucks all the time, from the Grey Cup.

 

[17to85]

https://youtu.be/iRjurRdep_Q?si=FWbHyaQKnsxRrsdq

[SpeedFlex27]

19 minutes ago, 17to85 said:

https://youtu.be/iRjurRdep_Q?si=FWbHyaQKnsxRrsdq

When you arrive at the outskirts of Edmonton from any direction.

[pw13]

On 2024-12-05 at 8:38 PM, SpeedFlex27 said:

Toronto who didn't play 10 or 11 Canadians won the Grey Cup by fielding the best team they possibly could by playing 7 Canadians. We didn't.  Trying so hard... not.... to.... mention... Jake... Thomas. 

For the record, in the Grey Cup Toronto started nine NATs (4 o-line, 2 receivers, DE-LB-S) and used one other (Mital) on a lot offensive snaps. 

 

 

[SpeedFlex27]

On 2024-12-14 at 2:04 PM, pw13 said:

For the record, in the Grey Cup Toronto started nine NATs (4 o-line, 2 receivers, DE-LB-S) and used one other (Mital) on a lot offensive snaps. 

 

 

i really don't care about other teams. I care about the Bombers. Am I supposed to be impressed by this? That Dinwiddie followed O'Shea's roster decisions by playing more Canadians than he could have? Not really. I didn't see a Canadian starter on the Argos even remotely close to the ineffectiveness of Jake Thomas. The Argos roster of Canadians were better than ours. It gave them flexibility. Our starting Canadians (in certain positions) hurt us. 

[Booch]

nothing wrong with starting an extra Canadian or using in heavy rotation....if they are good enough, AND...thats a big and...the best option...around here....it's not even a consideration with Osh.....and believe it of you want...or dont...but it hurts us and one could just imagine the even better success we could have had

[CrazyCanuck89]

On 2024-12-16 at 5:41 AM, SpeedFlex27 said:

i really don't care about other teams. I care about the Bombers. Am I supposed to be impressed by this? That Dinwiddie followed O'Shea's roster decisions by playing more Canadians than he could have? Not really. I didn't see a Canadian starter on the Argos even remotely close to the ineffectiveness of Jake Thomas. The Argos roster of Canadians were better than ours. It gave them flexibility. Our starting Canadians (in certain positions) hurt us. 

Other than Thomas, which other one hurt you.

Wasn't Ford

Wasn't Kramdi

What hurt you guys was a QB, who cut the finger on his throwing hand.

[GCn20]

1 hour ago, CrazyCanuck89 said:

Other than Thomas, which other one hurt you.

Wasn't Ford

Wasn't Kramdi

What hurt you guys was a QB, who cut the finger on his throwing hand.

Roster was not the issue in our loss whatsoever. Had no impact on the outcome at all.

[Tracker]

6 hours ago, CrazyCanuck89 said:

Other than Thomas, which other one hurt you.

Wasn't Ford

Wasn't Kramdi

What hurt you guys was a QB, who cut the finger on his throwing hand.

Collaros' finger injury was just the cherry on top of a dismal performance by the offence and an inability of the OC to compensate for the Argo defensive plan.

[17to85]

1 hour ago, Tracker said:

inability of the OC to compensate for the Argo defensive plan.

It's clear Pierce was out in vancouver closing the head coaching gig not game planning

[kelownabomberfan]

8 hours ago, CrazyCanuck89 said:

Other than Thomas, which other one hurt you.

Wasn't Ford

Wasn't Kramdi

What hurt you guys was a QB, who cut the finger on his throwing hand.

like a lot of football games, key plays going the Argos way hurt us big time - fumble by Fanny that the Argos recover, next play Lucky fumbles and Argos score a TD.  Had we recovered that fumble, who knows how the game goes.  Another killer was the screw up on the blocked punt.  Had Ayers or whoever it was not screwed up we would have had the ball in great field position, instead Argos keep the ball after a heroic D stand.  It was just a lot of mistakes, that we expect other teams to make, not us.

[Tracker]

20 hours ago, 17to85 said:

It's clear Pierce was out in vancouver closing the head coaching gig not game planning

Something like that. I don't know where his head was during the game, but I bet he could see his pancreas from there.

[wbbfan]

5 hours ago, Tracker said:

Something like that. I don't know where his head was during the game, but I bet he could see his pancreas from there.

I mean the entire season really. Hands down his worst year as a coach last year start to finish. 

[do or die]

We had already lost 2 games to the Argos, featuring total ineptitude on offense....expected some adjustments....then lost the Cup to them.....with bascially, the same crap.

Double Disappointment 

 

 

[TBURGESS]

We were the 3rd best team in the league last year. We were only in the cup because the top 2 were in the same division. 

[Fatty Liver]

40 minutes ago, TBURGESS said:

We were the 3rd best team in the league last year. We were only in the cup because the top 2 were in the same division. 

True, blasting past the inept Riders in the WF was a false flag.  Just re-watched that game and 3 of the Bombers TD's were scored on dropped coverage, it was too easy.  With the play of that secondary they really didn't deserve to get that far.