A Healthy Renaud - Does He Get Back In?

[TrueBlue]

I'm sure most of us could agree that Lirim has done pretty well in the punting department in relief if Renaud.  Hard to fathom that Renaud would have done any better.  

 

I do however think that Renaud poses a different kind of threat when it comes to the opportunities that he takes (i.e.: fielding his own punts) 

 

Does Renaud crack the lineup again, or have we seen the last of him?

 

I personally am not a fan of having just one kicker on the game day roster handling all kicking duties, but hard to argue with Haj's performance thus far.

 

 

[Mike]

I wouldn't be against seeing Renaud let go.

[Rich]

I think they've been waiting to see if another team's punter goes down this season to trade (and also to backup for the Bombers in case of injury).

 

If no biters, my bet is he is let go in the off season.

[TrueBlue]

Do you see it mostly to free up the roster spot, or because Lirim has performed that much better?  I'm not sure I see the difference.

 

Can't do it right now, but I would be curious to see some punting stats on Lirim so far.

[Rich]

Haven't seen the official stats between the two, but just watching them punt, I do believe Lirim has the stronger leg and het gets much better hang time on his punts.

[Jpan85]

It's nice to have that extra Canadian in the lineup to play SP teams

[gbill2004]

I figure this is Renaud's last season with the Bombers.

[FrostyWinnipeg]

Almost feels like they felt they got burned by letting Ford go and thought it would be best to keep Renaud around. I don't see the point unless its a ratio thing.

[Mr Dee]

Always am leery to release such a veteran, but Renaud just never hit that next level of improvement and consistency that guarantees security.

Although he throws a nice pass, no Renaud for us next year.

[Captain Blue]

Lirim > Renaud

[blitzmore]

Haven't seen the official stats between the two, but just watching them punt, I do believe Lirim has the stronger leg and het gets much better hang time on his punts.

If that was the case Liram would have won the punting duties out of TC

[Rich]

 

Haven't seen the official stats between the two, but just watching them punt, I do believe Lirim has the stronger leg and het gets much better hang time on his punts.

If that was the case Liram would have won the punting duties out of TC

 

 

Not necessarily.  Lirim was a rookie and sometimes if you give kickers too much to do both areas suffer.  At the TC practise I was at, I thought Lirim out kicked Renaud.

 

I think they wanted to ease Lirim in, letting him get comfortable and good at kicking while keeping some vet experience in the kicking game.  When Renaud got hurt, Lirim was given the opportunity to take over both jobs.

 

If Renaud was the better punter, he would be back by now.

[DR. CFL]

If Renaud is two inches taller and has a better vertical he might have a better chance fielding those deep snaps high into centre field

[mbrg]

I've found it odd how polarizing Renaud has been among fans.  He's a reasonably solid but unspectacular punter.  We've had far far worse - I know, high praise.

 

Lirim has been pretty good at the job.  I'm not sure he's been better all the time, but he's been better at minimum more than half the time, and he wins the leg strength battle handily.  Renaud is capable of better touch but can't do it consistently.  Right now I wouldn't use a spot on the 44 for him.  It's pretty unlikely he'll be back next year, but for now depth at every position is a good idea as the playoffs approach.

[mbrg]

 

 

Haven't seen the official stats between the two, but just watching them punt, I do believe Lirim has the stronger leg and het gets much better hang time on his punts.

If that was the case Liram would have won the punting duties out of TC

 

 

Not necessarily.  Lirim was a rookie and sometimes if you give kickers too much to do both areas suffer.  At the TC practise I was at, I thought Lirim out kicked Renaud.

 

I think they wanted to ease Lirim in, letting him get comfortable and good at kicking while keeping some vet experience in the kicking game.  When Renaud got hurt, Lirim was given the opportunity to take over both jobs.

 

If Renaud was the better punter, he would be back by now.

 

 

This is exactly what OShea said early on in the season when asked about the possibility of Lirim punting.  He'd rather let him become proficient at kicking than overwhelm him and have him be average at everything.

[DR. CFL]

Before people kick Renaud to the curb it might be wise to know who the next guy up is if Lirim were to get hurt. We have already demonstrated how lack of quality depth on the O line has been a serious issue, let's not do the same in the ST area, that is a huge factor in field position.

[FrostyWinnipeg]

Before people kick Renaud to the curb it might be wise to know who the next guy up is if Lirim were to get hurt. We have already demonstrated how lack of quality depth on the O line has been a serious issue, let's not do the same in the ST area, that is a huge factor in field position.

When has this team or any other team in the league had a backup kicker ready to go?

[TrueBlue]

Renaud:  3 games, 19 punts, 812 yards, 42.7 avg

 

Lirim: 9 games, 65 punts, 2877 yards, 44.2 avg

[sweep the leg]

Before people kick Renaud to the curb it might be wise to know who the next guy up is if Lirim were to get hurt. We have already demonstrated how lack of quality depth on the O line has been a serious issue, let's not do the same in the ST area, that is a huge factor in field position.

Next guy up would have to be a new American find. Renaud can't placekick to save his life so he's no help anywhere but punting.

[mbrg]

 

Before people kick Renaud to the curb it might be wise to know who the next guy up is if Lirim were to get hurt. We have already demonstrated how lack of quality depth on the O line has been a serious issue, let's not do the same in the ST area, that is a huge factor in field position.

When has this team or any other team in the league had a backup kicker ready to go?

 

 

Saskatchewan has Bartel on their 1 game and Palardy on their PR.

[mbrg]

Hamilton has Brett Lauther on their PR.

[mbrg]

Montreal has Nick Boyd on their PR.

[mbrg]

Edmonton had ONeill behind Shaw, still have Congi on their 1 game IR.

 

BC and Calgary both have split duty kickers on their rosters.  McCallum/Schmitt and Parades/Maver, respectively.

 

There are only two teams in the CFL who have one guy on their roster doing both duties without any backup - Toronto and Ottawa.

[gbill2004]

If Lirim gets injured in a game Kyle Jones is the backup kicker.

[blitzmore]

If Lirim gets injured in a game Kyle Jones is the backup kicker.

for place kicking and punting? ouch! That of course is providing they dump Renaud.